CA Prisoners Win Historic Gains with Settlement Against Solitary Confinement

Agreement reached in Ashker v. Brown ends indeterminate long-term solitary confinement in CA, among other gains for prisoners

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE – September 1, 2015
Prisoner Hunger Strike Solidarity Coalition

Oakland – Today, California prisoners locked in isolation achieved a groundbreaking legal victory in their ongoing struggle against the use of solitary confinement. A settlement was reached in the federal class action suit Ashker v. Brown, originally filed in 2012, effectively ending indefinite long-term solitary confinement, and greatly limiting the prison administration’s ability to use the practice, widely seen as a form of torture. The lawsuit was brought on behalf of prisoners held in Pelican Bay State Prison’s infamous Security Housing Units (SHU) for more than 10 years, where they spend 23 hours a day or more in their cells with little to no access to family visits, outdoor time, or any kind of programming.

“From the historic prisoner-led hunger strikes of 2011 and 2013, to the work of families, loved ones, and advocate, this settlement is a direct result of our grassroots organizing, both inside and outside prison walls,” said Dolores Canales of California Families Against Solitary Confinement (CFASC), and mother of a prisoner in Pelican Bay. “This legal victory is huge, but is not the end of our fight – it will only make the struggle against solitary and imprisonment everywhere stronger.” The 2011 and 2013 hunger strikes gained widespread international attention that for the first time in recent years put solitary confinement under mainstream scrutiny.

Currently, many prisoners are in solitary because of their “status” – having been associated with political ideologies or gang affiliation. However, this settlement does away with the status-based system, leaving solitary as an option only in cases of serious behavioral rule violations. Furthermore, the settlement limits the amount of time a prisoner may be held in solitary, and sets a two year Step-Down Program for the release of current solitary prisoners into the prison general population.

It is estimated that between 1,500 and 2,000 prisoners will be released from SHU within one year of this settlement. A higher security general population unit will be created for a small number of cases where people have been in SHU for more than 10 years and have a recent serious rule violation.

“Despite the repeated attempts by the prison regime to break the prisoners’ strength, they have remained unified in this fight,” said Marie Levin of CFASC and sister of a prisoner representative named in the lawsuit. “The Agreement to End Hostilities and the unity of the prisoners are crucial to this victory, and will continue to play a significant role in their ongoing struggle.” The Agreement to End Hostilities is an historic document put out by prisoner representatives in Pelican Bay in 2012 calling on all prisoners to build unity and cease hostilities between racial groups.

Prisoner representatives and their legal counsel will regularly meet with California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation officials as well as with Federal Magistrate Judge Nandor Vadas, who is tasked with overseeing the reforms, to insure that the settlement terms are being implemented.

“Without the hunger strikes and without the Agreement to End Hostilities to bring California’s prisoners together and commit to risking their lives— by being willing to die for their cause by starving for 60 days, we would not have this settlement today,” said Anne Weills of Siegel and Yee, co-counsel in the case. “It will improve the living conditions for thousands of men and women and no longer have them languishing for decades in the hole at Pelican Bay.”

“This victory was achieved by the efforts of people in prison, their families and loved ones, lawyers, and outside supporters,” said the prisoners represented in the settlement in a joint statement. “We celebrate this victory while at the same time, we recognize that achieving our goal of fundamentally transforming the criminal justice system and stopping the practice of warehousing people in prison will be a protracted struggle.”

Legal co-counsel in the case includes California Prison Focus, Siegel & Yee, Legal Services for Prisoners with Children, Weil Gotshal & Manges LLP, Chistensen O’Connor Johnson Kindness PLLC, and the Law Offices of Charles Carbone. The lead counsel is the Center for Constitutional Rights. The judge in the case is Judge Claudia Wilken in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California.

A rally and press conference are set for 12pm in front of the Elihu M Harris State Building in Oakland, which will be livestreamed at

The settlement can be read on CCR’s website, along with a summary. CCR has also put up downloadable clips of the plaintiffs’ depositions here.  Read statement from plaintiffs.

16 thoughts on “CA Prisoners Win Historic Gains with Settlement Against Solitary Confinement

  1. This is tremendous news. People throughout the world will rejoice at the prisoners’ victory. But the settlement doesn’t just mark a turning point for those behind bars. The entire society will benefit when the State of California ceases torturing its captives. Thanks and congratulations are due to the prisoners themselves and their legal team, the families who support the struggle, and even, dare I say it, Gerry Brown. He’s finally done the right thing (but only because he ran out of legal options).

  2. Pingback: Landmark Agreement Ends Indefinite Long-Term Solitary Confinement in California | Prison Photography

  3. Prisoners rights is something my Dad (Hugo L.A. Pinell ) fought for; 51 years later we see some justice and finally some change. It is a shame that after spending 46 years in the SHU he is not here to reap the benefits of the settlement. He paid the ultimate price in the SHU serving 46 years in solitary. 14 days after being released to GP he was murdered on the yard of CSP Folsom. We rejoice with the families and inmates for this victory and we join the ranks of the supporters to continue the fight.
    The Struggle Continues,

  4. Pingback: CA Prisoners Win Historic Gains with Settlement Against Solitary Confinement | Denver Anarchist Black Cross

  5. Pingback: CA Prisoners Win Historic Gains with Settlement Against Solitary Confinement | Prison Watch Network

  6. Pingback: A Week to Remember…While we Continue to Journey toward Justice | Human Rights Pen Pal

  7. Pingback: CA Prisoners Win Historic Gains with Settlement Against Solitary Confinement | Resumen LatinoAmericano English

  8. Pingback: Pressure Builds To Stop Sleep Deprivation in Pelican Bay SHU | Prisoner Hunger Strike Solidarity

  9. I’m Grateful for this Victory! , is real good to know that CDC Terrible System, and Wrongful Practice of Solitary Confinement No longer be allowed! I’m truyly happy for my cousin… knowing that he won’t be sent back to it again, without a reason! Thanks to the Prisoners Peaceful Protests l, their families and love ones, PHSS, F.A.S.C., CCR, and UN, and all other Campaings on behalf the Prisoners .

  10. Pingback: Bloc Party: Report back from ABC Conference (North America) | Prisoner Support Bristol ABC

  11. Capitalism is not a victimless crime. The system causes the crimes that put people into the ‘justice’ system – yes ALL-ANY of it.
    Street crime is prosecuted. Boardroom crime – including kings’ throne-rooms – are not prosecuted.
    Work to unite us to institute socialism-communism. That is the social structure for our benefit – by all of us – you know – us 99%. in Berkeley, Ca. U.S.A.

  12. Pingback: Sleep Deprivation for Almost Three Months! Help STOP It | Prisoner Hunger Strike Solidarity

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s